With regard to the missional movement’s understanding of Christendom, it is important to recognize that they saw what happened during this period as little more than the church contextualizing worship to the dominant culture of the civilization. Since Christianity happened to be the dominant religion of the western world, the church was able to easily reflect the culture around it and thus “attractional” evangelism thrived. But because the West has now moved beyond the Christendom era, missional writers insist that the church must once again learn how to contextualize worship to the dominant culture since one of the key values of the missional movement is incarnation.
For the missional church, worship forms must reflect the dominant cultural forms of the target group. Guder argues that worship services “must be substantially changed in many settings in our world.” ((Guder, The Continuing Converstion of the Church, 96.)) Stetzer likewise insists that “worship must take on the expression that reflects the culture of the worshiper if it is to be authentic and make an impact.” ((Stetzer and Putman, Breaking the Missional Code, 100.)) He sees this contextualization as a self-evident reality in which all churches take part when they use the common language of the people to whom they minister. Specifically addressing musical styles, Stetzer suggests that a church should seek to discover what styles are dominant in its target “focus group” and “adapt [its] own tunes an styles to the preferred styles of [its] focus group.” ((Ibid., 64.)) Contextualization is a significant emphasis of Hirsch who argues that “worship style, social dynamics, liturgical expressions must result from the process of contextualizing the gospel in any given culture.” ((Hirsch, The Forgotten Ways, 143.)) Driscoll based his entire church planting strategy on the principle of contextualization, arguing that churches must be willing to regularly change their worship forms “in an effort to effectively communicate the gospel to as many people as possible in the cultures around them.” ((Driscoll, Radical Reformission, 80.)) Likewise, according to Lepinski, “The need for the Church to remain effective in speaking the ‘current language’ and to successfully engage all people and age groups is a practice that can be seen in the life of Jesus. Christ’s earthly life manifests the importance of relevancy.” ((Lepinski, “Engaging Postmoderns in Worship,” 6.))
For all practical purposes, this implies a view of cultural neutrality, at least in the forms themselves if not always the content. Several authors mention that Christians will need to reject some elements of culture, but usually this refers to the subject matter of songs or movies, for example, rather than the cultural forms themselves. Various content may be immoral, but the culture itself is neutral. This is no more evident than when missional writers discuss music in worship. Guder insist that music must be “translated for the sake of the witness we are to be and do,” and says nothing about the possibility that certain styles might be unusable. ((Guder, The Continuing Converstion of the Church, 96.)) Stetzer specifically states that “there is no such thing as Christian music, only Christian lyrics” ((Stetzer, Planting Missional Churches, 267.)) and that “God has no preference regarding style,” ((Towns and Stetzer, Perimeters of Light: Biblical Boundaries for the Emerging Church, 43.)) implying that cultural forms are neutral and only lyrics may be judged as moral or immoral. Driscoll implies the neutrality of culture by insisting that “it was God who created cultures,” ((Driscoll, Radical Reformission, 80.)) thereby rendering various cultural forms intrinsically good. Parris gets to the root of the issue by insisting that since “a single biblical style is not commanded in Scripture,” ((Parris, “Instituting a Missional Worship Style in a Local Church Developed from an Analysis of the Culture,” 2.)) cultural styles are neutral. Since culture is inherently neutral according to missional advocates, contextualization becomes as simple as discovering the dominant cultural forms of a target group and reflecting them in worship. ((Van Gelder seems to be the only significant missional author who recognizes that cultural forms themselves may actually express meaning and shape content. See Van Gelder, “Missional Context: Understanding North American Culture,” 30–31.))
In missional thinking, two important reasons necessitate that worship must be contextualized. The first is that worship must be “intelligible” to unbelievers, which has already been discussed above. But the second reason worship must be contextualized is that even believers have been shaped by the dominant culture, and so for worship to be intelligible and even authentic for them, the forms used in worship should reflect the outside culture. Guder exemplifies this thinking when he says, “Our changing cultural context also requires that we change our worship forms so that Christians shaped by late modernity can express their faith authentically and honestly.” ((Guder, The Continuing Converstion of the Church, 157.)) Driscoll also implies this when he says that “God promised that people from every race, culture, language, and nation will be present to worship him as their culture follows them into heaven,” ((Driscoll, Radical Reformission, 100.)) which follows the same line of reasoning as Hirsch when he claims that “it is from within their own cultural expressions that the nations will worship.” ((Hirsch, The Forgotten Ways, 138.)) This reasoning is primary in Kimball’s thinking, who argues that “since worship is about our expressing love and adoration to God, and leaders teaching people about God, then of course the culture will shape our expressions of worship.” ((Kimball, Emerging Worship, 298.))