Today I’m back with another history curriculum review. So far we’ve looked at Veritas Press History, Story of the World, and Mystery of History. In this review, I’ll examine Classical Conversations history.
I have been receiving Classical Conversations catalogs in the mail for some time now. (If you homeschool or would like to, I’d strongly encourage you to sign up for as many free curriculum catalogs as you can find. The ones I currently get are Veritas Press, Memoria Press–which is a catalog/free magazine, , and Classical Academic Press. I also look at Logos Press online catalog. This will allow you to compare and contrast curricula choices.) Last summer, I had the opportunity to attend a Classical Conversations informational demo day. I was already familiar with what they had to offer through the catalog, but during the demo day I got to look through everything and see it put into action.
Here’s my caveat for this review: I’m only going to talk about the two history components of Classical Conversations today, and I’m going to restrict it to the “Foundations” (K4-6th) level.
Classical Conversations history component is taught in two parts, the timeline song and the “history sentence.” For the timeline song, Classical Conversations (CC from now on) offers Classical Acts and Fact History Cards in four packs (Ancient World, Medieval World, New World, Modern World) with 161 cards total (so, close to the same number as the Veritas cards). These cards are made of a sturdy cardstock with a laminated coating, so they hold up well and are wipeable. CC used to use Veritas Press timeline cards, so you may see those around in the CC community as well, but they’ve come out with their own cards recently that include some different events/people and more non-Western history than Veritas. However, unlike Veritas’s design of learning one set of cards per year, these cards are designed for all 161 card events/people to be learned in one year and then repeated every year.
Also for the timeline song, CC offers a CD with their own original song to go with the cards (the CD includes much more than the timeline song–see below), or just the timeline song can be purchased in a series of mp3 downloads on the CC website. Many (probably most) CC families and communities (CC exists as a co-op set-up, but their products are available to anyone) also use hand motions with the song. These vary from group to group and family to family, but a bunch of variations are available to view on YouTube.
For the history sentence, each week the child memorizes one sentence about an event or person in history. These sentences are found in the teacher’s guide (Foundations Guide). CC also offers a song that includes all the history sentences, and that’s available in CD format. These are not designed to be learned all in one year, but are spread out over three years/cycles: Ancient through Modern World History, World History from Pre-Reformation to Modern, and U.S. History. (The CD with this is a three-CD set which includes the timeline song, the history sentence songs, and other memory songs such as grammar songs and math songs. However, in order to get all the history sentences, you’ll have to purchase the 3-CD sets for all three cycles–so, three sets with three CDs in each.)
CC also sells printouts and visuals on a Memory Work Resource CD and small “Memory Master” flashcards for on-the-go. (Both of these include many more subjects than just history in the pack, but, again, you’ll have to purchase all three cycles in order to get all the history sentences.)
Before I move on, I just want to mention that CC also has a geography curriculum that goes along with their history, and I really like the CC approach to K-6th geography! The geography lessons are found in the Foundations Guide, and they also offer some other geography resources. But Leigh Bortins, the founder of CC, takes a very basic approach to geography in her book The Core, and that’s what we’re currently doing.
I believe that memory work is vital to the education of young children, when they can memorize so easily and soak it all in! CC is great on this concept, providing lots of memory pegs.
It includes important events in both Western history as well as non-Western history, which the Veritas cards lack.
Flexible to use with any core curriculum, since it just covers the memorization aspect of history in a chronological format
Lots of online helps, tips, and free resources from CC connected families all over the country (I especially like this blog for CC info and resources.)
I really like the idea of learning all the cards every year, rather than only learning the cards that go with the events we’re studying. To me, there’s more chance of memory retention if we’re repeating the same whole timeline song every year, from the ancients to the present. (This is doable. We just add 5 or 6 events every week and repeat it several times during the week.)
The timeline song music was not something I wanted my children to learn. If they’re going to be singing something over and over and over again, something where the goal is for them to know it for the rest of their life, I wanted it to be good quality music and not “beat-y” and cheesy. You can listen to the whole song for yourself here. (That’s the actual CD that someone has turned into a music video.) This is what your kids would learn if they attended a CC co-op group. For me, this just means not buying the CD. (I have another tune I use for our timeline song.)
There wasn’t enough church history integration for me to be satisfied with it as is.
It really needs a core curriculum to go along with it. In my opinion, just what CC offers isn’t enough. Many CC families that I’ve talked to supplement with Story of the World or Mystery of History. Some families supplement with living books also.
The history sentences use a three-year history cycle, which I think perhaps crams too much into three years, skipping over some major events. I personally much prefer at least a four-year cycle. Furthermore, the cycles are not chronological (though the timeline song, of course, is).
The cards are fairly pricey for what you’re buying, and the history sentences are found in the Foundations book, which is very expensive!
The cards don’t follow the Answers in Genesis/Ussher young earth timeline; I did have to rearrange some of the cards–so that’s an issue for those of you following a very young earth timeline for the ancient time period.
First of all, I’ll comment on why we’re not part of a CC co-op. We have one that meets in a church that’s less than a minute from our house, which is where I attended the demo day. I think it’s a great concept for the K4-6th grades. I’ve read the founder’s book, as I mentioned above. I like a lot of what she has to say, and I like a lot about what CC does each week.
At the end of the demo day I attended, I spent some time talking to the director of our local program. At some point in the conversation, I guess she discerned that I was familiar with Classical Christian education and asked me whether I would be willing to be one of the teachers for the upcoming year. (Students are divided into small groups for part of the time, and each group has a teacher, or tutor.) I will say at the outset that CC is expensive to enroll in (not like a school, of course, but still), plus you are strongly encouraged to buy the materials for your home as well. Being one of the tutors would have just barely defrayed that cost for me with two children enrolled (i.e., I would have been doing all the work for my own children plus other people’s children without adding to our family income). So, the expense was an issue.
But, despite the many things I really liked about CC, Scott and I decided against enrolling in CC Foundations for two main reasons. First, we were not comfortable with the music. CC uses music for almost everything. (It’s basically several hours of memory work set to music with an art or music lesson as well and a science experiment at the end.) The music they chose for this lifelong memory method just wasn’t something I wanted my children to learn. I really wish they had chosen something more classy and “classical” (not necessarily classical music, but something time-proven and beautiful) for Classical Conversations!
Second, I was uncomfortable with the tutor “vetting” process. This may differ from location to location, but it seemed to me like any interested mom could tutor if a spot was available. (There is a day-long training session, but they asked me to tutor after only knowing me for a few minutes, and no question was asked about my religious beliefs, etc.) Maybe I’m a control-freak, but that made me uncomfortable about who would be teaching my children. Parents are encouraged (required, even, I believe) to stay, though; it’s not a drop-off situation, so that does defray some of that concern.
Now, here’s how we use CC history in our home. I purchased the timeline cards (with 40% off coupons at Mardel) and I mixed them in with our Veritas timeline cards (which I got on craigslist). I don’t use all the cards in either set. I chose the ones I wanted my kids to memorize. (There was some overlap also.) We could have done our timeline song without any cards. That’s definitely doable for those who don’t want to make the purchase. However, both sets of cards have a nice piece of art on the front, which I thought would be a helpful visual memory peg for my kids (that’s what the picture is there for), and both sets have a few key facts on the back, which is handy. I put the cards in these binders with these plastic sleeves (both which I discovered at the CC demo day and which perfectly hold the Veritas and CC cards), and we flip through them every day that we sing our timeline song. Using the binders and sleeves will, I hope, make them last for years to come! (I have one binder for the ancients through the middle ages and another binder for the reformation through the present day.) We don’t use the history sentences at all.
I will be sharing the words and tune, as well as the motions, to our family’s timeline song in another post coming up soon! I’ll also share a post that lists all the events on both the CC timeline cards as well as the Veritas cards so you can pick and choose for yourself what you’d like your kids to learn.
Applicability to Non-Homeschool Families
Non-homeschooling families can learn a timeline song just as easily as homeschooling families. It only takes a couple minutes a day, and in no time, your kids (and you!) will have memorized a basic skeleton for what has happened and when it happened throughout the history of the world. If your kids are not learning a history timeline in school, I’d strongly encourage you to reap the benefits of doing this. In fact, many of CC’s ideas for various subjects would be a simple way to give your kids some of the benefits of classical education if they’re not already getting one.